Discussion about this post

User's avatar
false10's avatar

I don't think grading transfers right after the window closes is asinine. Quite the opposite.

Since neither the club nor you know the future, when you grade a transfer right after, you do it on (roughly) equal terms based on the present information. You take stuff like age, approximate player quality, likely projections of player development, fee/wage and square that with the squad age, squad quality, goals, financial situation etc. Then you ask yourself whether your evaluation is in line with the club's.

Grading a transfer in real-time is closer to evaluating the club's process behind it which is the thing that actually matters.

Grading transfers in hindsight might introduce outcome bias. For example, a player exceeding expectations doesn't automatically mean the transfer itself was sensible when it happened. It might have been an extremely unlikely development path the club shouldn't have banked on. (Not saying that's what you fall for, your ratings are on point.)

Where it does help is in providing more information you couldn't have known at the time. It might shine a light on whether it was a player the coach demanded or special knowledge the club had.

Take the current window. Based on what I know about Cunha and Mbeumo I think they're bad transfers. Two prime age players commanding big fees and wages. The biggest problem is they massively overperformed their xG over last season but are roughly on par over their whole career. So United's paying for production they're very unlikely to maintain. It would take a lot to make me reconsider my opinion in five years.

Expand full comment
Emmanuel Boakye's avatar

Murtough and ETH accelerated the decline in our spending power if you look at the spend in their two years together. I think the jury is still out on last year's window. We bought a FB for 15m in Mazraoui, that's a great value pick up and I would argue the fee for MDL is also good considering Max Kilman went for 40m in the same window.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts